WRU supposed talks to drop Ospreys – a farce

With the Christmas and New year Derbys over with, they provided a much needed boost to attendances in Welsh rugby over the holiday period, even if the rugby on display was not much to savour.

The Dragons, Blues and Scarlets are all in a poor run of form, yet the West Wales region still remains second in the RaboDirect PRO12. The Ospreys were the only region to produce any good play over the holiday period, with convincing and commanding displays over both the Scarlets and Dragons, moving themselves up to joint 5th in the league, just shy of a play off spot.

The biggest news to have emerged over the last week however is that of the new revelations of the apparent discussions held by the WRU over the demise of the Ospreys.

Last season there were rumours abounding over all the region’s financial affairs, with strong murmurings over the solidity of the Ospreys, with them having faced a postponed winding up order over an unpaid tax bill.

It would appear instead of discussing with the Ospreys a way of improving their situation, the WRU instead held talks over how best to replace the Swansea based region, even apparently going so far as to have talks with the  Scarlets for them to base their next season’s recruitment policy with the availability of Ospreys players in mind.

Whilst you could argue that it could be prudent for a nation’s union to put plans in place for how best to cope with a failure of a region, it should never be that union’s first option.

The WRU did not wait for the Price Waterhouse Cooper (PWC) report to be finished before supposedly pushing forward with the talks. Talks that, if reports are to be believed, did not include the Ospreys.

We have the apparent situation of a union, instead of doing its utmost to save their most successful region were putting in place talks and proposals as to how to continue without them.

It beggars belief if true that the WRU did not put the safeguarding over an established region first, did not wait to discover the true facts over that regions’ finances before starting talks, and then going behind that region’s back to decide their future.

The WRU have claimed that all statements are incorrect and defamatory, yet the quotes from Rob Davies, an investor in the Ospreys, would appear to have at least some substance behind them.

The PWC report found the Ospreys to be the strongest of the four regions. History in the PRO12 and Celtic league show them to be the most successful. The fact that the WRU could have discussed plans to get rid of them without facts and without open discussion, if true, is nothing short of scandalous.

With reports from Roger Lewis in the last couple of weeks that the WRU are even considering going to three regions and one development region alarm bells should be ringing throughout the regions. If even a modicum of the statements about the WRU conduct are proven true then Welsh rugby appears to be re-entering the murky waters fans would have hoped it had long left behind. Closed negotiations and the exclusions of regions in talks has been seen before. What resulted was the demise of the Celtic Warriors.

The WRU board along with Roger Lewis need to take a good look at how they are to run a professional organisation. As more and more reports appear it would appear that they are still stuck in an amateur mind set where ego’s, self-serving ideals and the inability to conduct open negotiations are still rampant. 


One thought on “WRU supposed talks to drop Ospreys – a farce

  1. Where is the ego in getting rid of the Ospreys? Where is the self serving ideals? Why should a management organisation conduct “open negotiations”? The simple, inescapable fact for anyone who has their eyes open, is that the Welsh Regions are not capable of producing a sustainable brand. What is the brand? Rugby, not the name or the colours. Do the Regions play well? More often than not no.

    Its awfully tiresome to hear someone bang the drum for the regions as if they deserve anything other than opprobrium for the tosh they produce for loyal fans and for the money they have chucked down the drain for the last ten years.

    The other inescapable fact is that the WRU would be foolish to get rid of the Ospreys as they are the most succesful Welsh Region. That decision will have nothing to do with ego, or self serving ideals, it would be stupidity. However, unless we are part of the inner workings of the organisations involved we will never know exactly what is happening behing closed doors.

    At the present moment in time, Welsh Rugby is not sustaining 4 Regions, just the same as it didn’t sustain five. Welsh Rugby is struggling to keep its head above water, and the blame does not solely lay with the WRU. The fans of any of the regions would be up in aems if they were disbanded.

    Personally, I would far rather see our best players concentrated in a couple of teams rather than spread around the Prinicipality. But the average one-eyed, village idiot, Welsh Rugby fan would have none of that, just the same as the average Welsh Rugby fan spat their dummies when the Regions were introduced. If the WRU have to look at professionalism, so do the Regions. The sooner the boards and the fans of each region realised this, as well as the WRU, the sooner Welsh Rugby might move forward.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s